Skip to content
Current News & Events

Trepp: Failed CMBS Workouts Climb as Foreclosures Replace Loan Extensions

Trepp finds that one in five recent CMBS workouts returned to special servicing within a year, while foreclosure resolutions are rising.

Illustrative glass office tower, not identified with Trepp CMBS workouts

Share this article!

Summary

Trepp November 17 2026: 20% of 2024-25 CMBS workouts returned to special servicing within one year versus 12% in 2022-23; 2026 YTD modifications 37% and foreclosures 23% of resolved balance. Primary https://www.trepp.com/trepptalk/failed-cmbs-workouts-rise-extend-and-pretend-bill. Image 100616 Leohoho/Unsplash 2880x1920.

Commercial real estate lenders are confronting the limits of a strategy that gave troubled borrowers more time to recover. A November 17 analysis from Trepp finds that 20% of commercial mortgage-backed securities workouts completed in 2024 and 2025 returned to special servicing within a year, compared with 12% for workouts from 2022 and 2023.

The pattern raises questions about how much distress loan extensions actually resolved. In many cases, a maturity extension bought time without eliminating the underlying pressure from financing costs, property cash flow and valuations. Trepp’s analysis of special-servicing outcomes provides a more granular view of that risk than a single delinquency rate.

Foreclosures take a larger share

Modifications accounted for 54% of loan balances resolved from special servicing in 2024, but only 37% through October 2026, according to Trepp. Foreclosures represented 23% of resolved balances in 2026, up from 17% in 2025. Payoffs accounted for 24% of 2026 resolutions, while cures made up 16%.

Those figures measure shares of resolved loan balances, not the percentage of all outstanding CMBS loans. They should not be read as a forecast that nearly a quarter of the entire market will be foreclosed upon.

Office properties face the steepest redefault risk

Trepp reports that 29% of recent office workouts returned to special servicing within a year, compared with 16% in the earlier 2022–2023 cohort. The comparable rate rose to 21% for retail and 19% for lodging. Multifamily had a lower recent rate of 10%, but that too exceeded the earlier cohort’s 8%.

As of October, $71.7 billion of CMBS debt remained in special servicing, five times the level in October 2019. Of that balance, 43% had been in special servicing for at least two years. These extended timelines matter to investors and property owners because unresolved loans can delay sales, refinancing and reinvestment.

Why the distinction matters

Loan modifications are not inherently evidence of failure. Some borrowers regain stability after a maturity extension or other restructuring, and Trepp’s study acknowledges differing Federal Reserve research on lender incentives. The newer CMBS outcomes nonetheless suggest that a growing subset of loans requires a more permanent resolution.

WRE News recently reported on Trepp’s separate analysis of nearly $100 billion in modified CMBS loans. That report measured the current condition of modified debt; the November 17 analysis focuses on what happens after loans leave special servicing. Together they illustrate why an extension alone is not the same as a successful workout.

Primary source: Trepp, November 17, 2026.

Featured photograph is illustrative and does not depict a property in Trepp’s loan dataset. Photo: Leohoho / Unsplash.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *